Storm 1: Tuesday, Nov 3
Storm notes · Nov 4, 2026
Every storm, we compare what Storm Gap said with what actually happened on the passes, then we fix what we got wrong. This is the first one.
Storm grade: 57%. Details and how we grade are below.
The storm
A quick, showery system crossed the Sierra Tuesday afternoon and evening. Radar-measured precipitation on the summit stretches:
- Donner (I-80): about 0.5" of water, in two rounds: 1–5 PM and 6–9 PM
- Echo (US-50): about 0.3", mostly 1–5 PM
- Carson (SR-88): about 0.3", mostly 1–4 PM, plus a little after 8 PM
No pass closed.
What we said vs. what happened
| Pass | What Storm Gap said | What happened | How we did |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner | Open, no chains expected | Open. Chain controls probably went up for a few hours in the evening | Missed the chains |
| US-50 Echo | Chains likely from 4 PM; our 1 PM update raised it to closure risk | Open, no chain controls at all | False alarm |
| SR-88 Carson | Chains likely 4–10 PM | R-2 midday, lifted around 4 PM, back on around 8:40 PM and still on Wednesday morning | Right that chains would be on, wrong on timing and how long |
We got the most important call right everywhere: no closures. But it wasn't a clean night.
What went wrong
The heavy band hit Donner, not Echo. Our 1 PM forecast put an intense burst of snow right over Echo Summit in the early evening. It landed about 30 miles north, over Donner. One misplaced band caused both the Echo false alarm and the Donner miss.
We trusted one hour too much. A single forecast hour of heavy snow was enough to flag "closure risk." That's too jumpy for a forecast that can be 30 miles off.
Chains outlast the snow. At Carson, the afternoon snow fell on warm pavement and Caltrans lifted chains around 4 PM. A little snow after dark on a freezing road brought them back, and they stayed on overnight. We assumed chains come off a couple of hours after the snow stops. At night, they don't.
What we changed
- Closure risk needs agreement. It now takes two forecast runs in a row showing it, and heavy snow lasting at least two hours, before we say "closure risk."
- Less weight on any one model. We now blend our main forecast model with the National Weather Service's National Blend of Models, and we look at the area around each point on the pass instead of a single spot. One misplaced band can't drive the call by itself anymore.
- Chains through the night. After snow on a pass, we now expect chain controls to hold overnight while the road stays below freezing.
Replaying Tuesday with these changes, Echo would have said "chains likely" instead of "closure risk," and Carson would have called the overnight chains. It's not all upside: the overnight rule would also have kept "chains possible" on Echo all night, which didn't happen, and Donner would still have been missed. That one was a forecast that simply had too little snow in it, and no rule fixes that. More storms will tell us how well these changes hold up.
The grade: 57%
We grade the forecast a driver would have seen about three hours before snow started on each pass. That's the one you'd use to plan, not the best one in hindsight. Each pass gets three calls, each scored 0 to 1:
- Closure: did we call it right that the pass would or wouldn't close?
- Chains: did we call it right that chain controls would or wouldn't go up?
- Timing: how much our predicted chain period overlapped the real one.
| Pass | Closure | Chains | Timing | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner | ✓ | ✗ | 0 | 33% |
| US-50 Echo | ✓ | ✗ | 0 | 33% |
| SR-88 Carson | ✓ | ✓ | 0.1 | 70% |
| Storm 1 | 57% |
We counted Donner's chains as a miss even though we're only fairly sure they went up. We'd rather grade ourselves too hard than too easy.
How we score
We use radar-measured precipitation (NOAA's MRMS) for what fell, and Caltrans' chain-control and highway-condition reports for what happened on the road. We'll post a scorecard like this after every storm, misses included.
See something we got wrong? Use the feedback button in the app. Those notes go straight into the next fix.
See the live forecast