Storm 2: Friday, Nov 13
Storm notes · Nov 14, 2026
Every storm, we compare what Storm Gap said with what actually happened on the passes, then we fix what we got wrong. This is the second one.
Storm grade: 74%, up from 57% for Storm 1. We got the chains right on every pass, but we missed the hours that mattered most on Donner.
The storm
A wetter, colder system arrived Friday around midday and snowed into the night. Radar-measured precipitation (water, not snow depth) on the summit stretches, noon Friday to 9 AM Saturday:
- Donner (I-80): about 1.0–1.1" of water, steadiest from noon to 7 PM, at roughly 0.15–0.2" an hour. As snow, that's about an inch and a half to two inches an hour.
- Echo (US-50): about 1.2–1.3", heaviest from 1 to 7 PM.
- Carson (SR-88): about 1.0–1.4", steady from 1 to 8 PM.
Chain controls went up on all three passes, and I-80 closed over Donner Friday evening.
- Donner (I-80): chains from 1:21 PM. Traffic was held at Kingvale at 1:41 PM and again from about 3:30 to 4 PM. Closed from Colfax to the Nevada line from about 5:50 PM until 9:53 PM eastbound (westbound reopened at 7:42 PM). Closed to big rigs overnight, with chains still on Saturday morning.
- Echo (US-50): chains from 3:18 PM, traffic held at Meyers around 5:30 PM, then chains until 8:18 AM Saturday. No closure.
- Carson (SR-88): chains from 1:06 PM until about 8:40 AM Saturday. No closure.
What we said vs. what happened
This is the forecast from 11 AM Friday, about two hours before chains went up.
| Pass | What Storm Gap said | What happened | How we did |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner | Chains likely from 3 PM, closure risk 4–5 PM, then chains likely until 10 PM | Chains at 1:21 PM, holds from 1:41 PM, closed about 5:50–9:53 PM | Right that it would close, wrong about when. We called the closure hours "chains likely." |
| US-50 Echo | Chains from 3 PM, closure risk 5–6 PM and again after midnight | Chains at 3:18 PM, a short hold around 5:30 PM, no closure | Chains spot on. The 5–6 PM call caught the hold, but the after-midnight closure risk was a false alarm. |
| SR-88 Carson | Chains possible all morning, closure risk 3–6 PM and 8 PM–2 AM | Chains at 1:06 PM, overnight chains, no closure | Chains right, closure was a false alarm |
What went wrong
Donner closed while we said "chains likely." This is the miss that matters. If you checked Storm Gap at 5 PM, it told you to go with chains, and I-80 closed less than an hour later and stayed closed for four hours. Our forecast had heavy snow, one to two inches an hour at the summit, but our closure rule wanted two inches an hour for two hours straight. Caltrans closed it anyway.
It wasn't the snow alone. It was the traffic. All three passes got about the same amount of precipitation. Echo actually got a little more than Donner, and Echo and Carson never closed. What Donner had that the others didn't was Friday-evening Tahoe traffic on an interstate, and the spinouts that come with it. Caltrans had already been holding traffic at Kingvale for spinouts since early afternoon.
Chains came early on Donner. They went up at 1:21 PM. We had 3 PM.
Carson got "closure risk" and stayed open. Carson got as much precipitation as the other passes, so we can't blame it on less snow. Early in the season, Caltrans has room to push plowed snow off the side of the road. Later in a big winter that changes: SR-88 is narrow, the snow walls can reach 30 feet, and Carson closes much faster once there's nowhere to put the snow. Our closure rule doesn't know any of that yet.
What we changed
- Busy-evening closure risk on Donner (live now). On Friday and Sunday afternoons and evenings (2 to 10 PM), when snow is sticking at an inch an hour or more for two hours, Donner now shows "closure risk" instead of "chains likely." Replaying Friday's 11 AM forecast with this rule moves the closure-risk window from 4–5 PM to 3–7 PM. That covers the holds and the start of the closure, but not the last three hours: the snow eased after 7 PM, and the road stayed closed while Caltrans cleared it. Next we'll look at keeping closure risk up for a few hours after heavy snow on busy nights.
- Carson, later in the winter. We're not changing Carson's rules yet. Once the snowpack builds, we'll lower its closure bar as the snow walls get taller.
The grade: 74%
We grade the forecast a driver would have seen a few hours before snow started on each pass. That's the one you'd use to plan, not the best one in hindsight. Each pass gets three calls, each scored 0 to 1:
- Closure: did we call it right that the pass would or wouldn't close?
- Chains: did we call it right that chain controls would or wouldn't go up?
- Timing: how much our predicted chain period overlapped the real one.
| Pass | Closure | Chains | Timing | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner | ½ | ✓ | 0.9 | 81% |
| US-50 Echo | ½ | ✓ | 1.0 | 82% |
| SR-88 Carson | ✗ | ✓ | 0.7 | 58% |
| Storm 2 | 74% |
Donner gets half credit for the closure. We said it was at risk of closing, and it did, but our closure window was 4–5 PM and the real closure ran from about 5:50 to 9:53 PM. We graded the forecast as published, before this week's changes. Echo gets half credit because we called closure risk and Caltrans held traffic but never closed the road.
How we score
We use radar-measured precipitation (NOAA's MRMS) for what fell, and Caltrans' highway-condition and chain-control reports for what happened on the road, logged every 30 minutes. We'll post a scorecard like this after every storm, misses included.
See something we got wrong? Use the feedback button in the app. Those notes go straight into the next fix.
See the live forecast