Storm 3: Sunday to Tuesday, Nov 15–17
Storm notes · Nov 17, 2026
Every storm, we compare what Storm Gap said with what actually happened on the passes, then we fix what we got wrong. This is the third one.
Storm grade: 86%, up from 57% and 74% for the first two storms. No pass closed for weather, and Storm Gap didn't say any would. The chains were on time. The misses were at the tail end: chains stayed up, or came back, longer than we expected.
The storm
A long, steady system moved in Sunday night and snowed through Monday afternoon. Radar-measured precipitation (water, not snow depth) on the summit stretches, Sunday evening to Tuesday midday:
- Donner (I-80): about 0.7–1.3" of water, steadiest from midnight to 10 AM Monday at around 0.1" an hour. As snow, that's roughly an inch an hour.
- Echo (US-50): about 0.7–1.2", heaviest from 4 to 10 AM Monday.
- Carson (SR-88): about 1.3" at most points along the pass, steady from 3 AM to 2 PM Monday.
What happened on the road:
- Donner (I-80): chains from midnight Sunday to 8 PM Monday. Westbound traffic was held at Truckee for spinouts at 5:28 AM Monday. Chains came back at 12:30 AM Tuesday and came off at 11 AM. Early Tuesday, eastbound was closed between Colfax and Cisco for a disabled big rig.
- Echo (US-50): chains from 4:30 AM to 3 PM Monday, and again from 5 to 8 AM Tuesday. Westbound was closed near Meyers for a while Monday morning because of a crash.
- Carson (SR-88): chains from 2:50 AM Monday, with a short break around 7 AM, and still up at noon Tuesday.
We grade the weather, not the crashes: the big-rig closure on I-80 and the crash on US-50 aren't counted against or for the forecast.
What we said vs. what happened
This is the forecast from a few hours before chains went up on each pass.
| Pass | What Storm Gap said | What happened | How we did |
|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner (Sunday 9 PM forecast) | Chains from 4 AM to 10 PM Monday, no closure risk | Chains from midnight to 8 PM Monday, back from 12:30 to 11 AM Tuesday, a spinout hold, no weather closure | Right about no closure. Chains started 4 hours earlier than we said, and we missed Tuesday morning entirely. |
| US-50 Echo (Monday 1 AM forecast) | Chains from 4 AM to 10 PM Monday, no closure risk | Chains from 4:30 AM to 3 PM Monday, back from 5 to 8 AM Tuesday | Start time spot on. We kept chains on 7 hours too long Monday night and missed Tuesday morning. |
| SR-88 Carson (Sunday 11 PM forecast) | Chains from 4 AM Monday to 5 AM Tuesday, no closure risk | Chains from 2:50 AM Monday, still up at noon Tuesday | Close on the start. Chains stayed up 7 hours longer than we said. |
What went right
No false alarms. After two storms where Carson got "closure risk" and stayed open, this storm we called it right on all three passes: chains, not closures. That's the call that matters most if you're deciding whether to go.
What went wrong
The morning after. On all three passes, chains outlasted the snow. Donner and Echo got chains again early Tuesday after a dry evening, and Carson's never came off. The radar shows only a trace of new precipitation overnight, so this was mostly the road refreezing after a long, wet storm, plus Caltrans keeping chains up until crews had the road clear. Storm Gap already keeps chains up overnight when the road is frozen, but only right after heavy snow. Monday's storm was long and steady rather than heavy, so that rule didn't kick in.
Donner started early. Chains went up at midnight; we said 4 AM. The snow arrived a few hours sooner than the forecast had it.
What we're changing
- Keep chains possible the morning after a long storm. When several inches have stuck over the past day and the road is forecast to stay below freezing overnight, Storm Gap will keep "chains possible" through the next morning, even if the last hours of snow were light. This is a proposal: we're testing it against all three storms before turning it on.
The grade: 86%
We grade the forecast a driver would have seen a few hours before snow started on each pass. That's the one you'd use to plan, not the best one in hindsight. Each pass gets three calls, each scored 0 to 1:
- Closure: did we call it right that the pass would or wouldn't close for weather?
- Chains: did we call it right that chain controls would or wouldn't go up?
- Timing: how much our predicted chain period overlapped the real one.
| Pass | Closure | Chains | Timing | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I-80 Donner | ✓ | ✓ | 0.5 | 83% |
| US-50 Echo | ✓ | ✓ | 0.5 | 83% |
| SR-88 Carson | ✓ | ✓ | 0.7 | 91% |
| Storm 3 | 86% |
How we score
We use radar-measured precipitation (NOAA's MRMS) for what fell, and Caltrans' highway-condition and chain-control reports for what happened on the road, logged every 30 minutes. One correction while we're at it: on Monday and Tuesday the app showed "Chains R-3" on I-80 when cars actually had R-2. It was reading Caltrans' truck screening as a chain level for everyone. That's fixed.
We'll post a scorecard like this after every storm, misses included. See something we got wrong? Use the feedback button in the app.
See the live forecast